Full Recipe
Author
Sarah Jampel | 2025-06-18
Description
If you consider a PB&J to be one of the world's great sandwiches, these peanut butter and jelly cookies are for you. Big and crinkly with bendy centers, crisp edges, and a salty-sweet coating, these sandwich-inspired cookies get their jelly flavor from Jammy Bits, little jewels of concentrated fruit flavor that stay suspended throughout the cookies in a way proper jam never could. Once you've secured your bag of Jammy Bits, these peanut butter and jelly cookies come together easily — no special equipment or softened butter required — which means you'll be tucking them into lunchboxes in no time.
